Full feedback review: what changed and what remains

Corpus programme

Partly complete

Inventories and reading routes exist; complete item-by-item reading of all private holdings, FPCS, Monoskop, SysCoI/model.report, and the SFI podcast remains a research programme.

Inspect the result or current route

Map navigation and representations

Implemented in 0.31

Refocus preserves layer, family, and scale. Graph and card state has real links, edge selection survives reload, and modified clicks keep browser behaviour.

Inspect the result or current route

Canonical reading and developed entries

Partly complete

Canonical and named-entry coverage exists. Further primary-source depth and editorial review are required; presence is not a full-text-reading claim.

Inspect the result or current route

Editorial roles and participation

Available; stewardship work remains

Email corrections work without a GitHub account. Public issue status remains visible. Named stewards and curators, rather than AI, own acceptance decisions; no access rights or invitations changed.

Inspect the result or current route

Attribution, visibility, and lineage

Partly complete

The reader now states map principles explicitly. Documentary visibility is separated from identity inference; human lineage and exclusion claims still require evidence.

Inspect the result or current route

Living marks

Implemented previously

Still and moving marks, playback control, random selection, and reduced-motion handling remain available.

Inspect the result or current route

Public wording and source precision

Implemented; continuing audit

Standalone prose, full names, source locators, and explicit candidate labels are retained. New route copy follows these constraints.

Inspect the result or current route

Iteration observations

Refreshed in 0.31

Graph measurements are recalculated. The new observation distinguishes bibliographic access, conceptual evidence, and human review.

Inspect the result or current route

Comparator programme

Partly complete

Existing comparators preserved; all 307 Castellani destinations checked. Rights, 28 label disagreements, reconciliation, and reproducibility limits remain explicit.

Inspect the result or current route

Named missing entries and method lists

Covered by prior releases; depth varies

Named coverage and unFIX 32 have published registers. These establish admission and coverage, not equal depth or universal endorsement.

Inspect the result or current route

Training and learning home

Implemented in 0.31

Dedicated directory connects SCiO, PSTA, RedQuadrant, university and free learning, both Leading Transformation sequences, and source-led guides.

Inspect the result or current route

David Ing and Understanding Systems

Deepened in 0.31

The full published pro forma is now read and linked module by module. It is a proposal for discussion; linked books are not all represented as read.

Inspect the result or current route

Practice criticisms and teaching routes

Addressed with bounded applications

Exercises distinguish a useful inquiry from a universal claim about methods, purposes, or organisations. Practitioner disagreements are attributed.

Inspect the result or current route

ISSS resources and Systems Sciences stewardship

Deepened in 0.31

The student bibliography is extracted by category, with modelling tools and wider society routes. David Ing stewardship approval is recorded; human adoption remains distinct from AI assistance.

Inspect the result or current route

Rational Understanding researcher modules

Read and integrated in 0.31

All five PDFs, 32 pages, were read. Typed, located candidate claims distinguish Challoner’s reconstruction from direct original-author evidence.

Inspect the result or current route

OrgLens

Deepened in 0.31

The requested second development article is read. Plain-language reporting and evidence checks are documented; fictional cases and AI readers do not establish effectiveness with real organisations.

Inspect the result or current route

Historical release report

Historical record

A release or deployment report, retained as history rather than counted as a new unresolved request.

Inspect the result or current route

Guiding principles and map inheritance

Implemented, with source gaps recorded

The map critiques inform explicit editorial principles. The available map texts are reconciled by bibliographic identity; the full image-only folder inventory remains unverified.

Inspect the result or current route

#2: Running feedback for the next iteration

Full comment-by-comment disposition is now published; open actions remain linked.

#3: Corpus pass: Foundational Papers in Complexity Science

Complete primary-paper reading and claim-level review beyond the existing inventory.

#4: Corpus pass: relevant Monoskop material for systems | cybernetics | complexity

A finite admission/exclusion register for relevant source items, with locators.

#5: Archive pass: SysCoI and model.report as historical evidence and discovery corpora

Repeatable complete-archive ingestion and item-level review, beyond recent-post intake.

#6: Comparator pass: prior maps, bodies of knowledge and the Castellani complexity map critique

Human reconciliation and independent evidence for proposed canonical relations.

#7: Lineage model: map practitioner influence constellations, teaching and collaboration

Source-located teaching, collaboration, correspondence, and influence claims; no automated identity inference.

#8: Discovery pass: company knowledge and public-source replacement

Complete folder inventory and lawful public replacements; private holdings remain private.

#10: Governance: membership roles, access and agent-assisted contributions

Human decisions on membership and responsibility; no changes to GitHub access.

#11: Map v2: richer layers, usable zoom and emergent neighbourhoods

Navigation repairs are delivered; further emergent grouping requires justified semantics and reader evaluation.

#12: Corpus pass: Principia Cybernetica and canonical public source register

Maintain the existing register and deepen source-specific coverage rather than equating listing with reading.

#68: [Source] International Encyclopedia of Systems and Cybernetics

Precise bibliographic and proposition-level reconciliation with the atlas.

#71: Participation: Systems Sciences

David Ing’s approval is recorded; actual stewardship decisions and reviews remain human work.

#78: Participation: Michael C. Jackson and the Systems Sciences

Verify each substantive claim and scope the comparison; retain unresolved disputed assertions.

#79: [Source] Michael C. Jackson vs. Dave Snowden — Building on 2023 U Hull lecture and discussion

Compare located published responses and video timestamps before accepting the submitted interpretation.