The Necessary Tangle

Historical sources · 1948–1957

Reading cybernetics as it took shape

Wiener’s selected reading, technical books, conference records, and popular treatments, alongside Barrett and Shepard’s explanation of their bibliography.

Historical material shared by Sean Manion, @TheUnjournaling, and transcribed on Systems Community of Inquiry. The original compilers and publication authors retain their separate credits.

Follow the reading journeyBrowse all 48 entriesDownload the catalogue

What you can inspect here

Wiener’s lists

All 48 transcribed entries are retained: eight selected readings, 20 short-bibliography entries, 15 popular treatments, and five popular pieces by Wiener. They resolve to 45 distinct atlas works; one issue reference remains unidentified.

Four entries have selected primary passages reviewed, and Ashby’s 1946 title has an archive metadata check. The remaining entries have a bibliographic account. This is not a claim that every paper has been read.

Barrett and Shepard

The linked post supplies three pages of introduction. It describes six categories and names two illustrative books, but contains none of the bibliography’s hundreds of entries. Those missing pages are needed for a full paper-by-paper pass.

The byline is F. Dermot Barrett and Herbert A. Shepard. The source URL’s spelling ‘Shephard’ is retained only as part of its address.

Two source posts, three original shares

The dated 1952 list is distinct from the approximate 1951 popular list and the short bibliography described as 1956. That last list includes Cherry’s 1957 book; its exact date needs the archival typescript. No silent correction has been made.

The six categories of the 1951 bibliography

These are the compilers’ categories, framed for social scientists. They remain a historical classification, with overlaps acknowledged in the introduction.

  1. Popular Expositions
  2. Cybernetics
  3. Information Theory and Communication Theory
  4. Servomechanisms
  5. Cybernetics Concepts in the Biological and Social Sciences
  6. Relevant Works in Social Science, Biology, and Philosophy

Open the bibliography’s atlas entry.

The Wisdom of the Body

Named in the introduction as strongly consonant with cybernetics. This is the compilers’ assessment.

The Functions of the Executive

Named as a less clear-cut inclusion for scattered insights. This does not establish a cybernetic theory of organisation.

Every available entry

Search the original wording, author, title, or note. An atlas link identifies a work; the review label says how far the evidence pass has gone.

48 source entries.

  1. Selected readings, 21 March 1952

    The Behavioral Properties of Systems in Equilibrium

    Ashby, W. R. ‘The Behavioral Properties of Systems in Equilibrium.’ American Journal of Psychology, Vol. 59 (1946), 682–6.

    Archive metadata checked

    Open the primary text or archive record

    Ashby’s archive supplies the fuller title: Dynamics of the Cerebral Cortex: The Behavioral Properties of Systems in Equilibrium. Original citation retained.

  2. Selected readings, 21 March 1952

    Life, Thermodynamics, and Cybernetics

    Brillouin, L. ‘Life, Thermodynamics, and Cybernetics.’ American Scientist, Vol. 37 (Oct. 1949), 554–568.

    Bibliographic record only
  3. Selected readings, 21 March 1952

    Transactions of the Sixth Conference on Cybernetics

    Conference on Cybernetics. Transactions of the Sixth Conference on Cybernetics. March 24–25, 1949. New York, the Josiah Macy, Jr. Foundation.

    Bibliographic record only
  4. Selected readings, 21 March 1952

    Transactions of the Seventh Conference on Cybernetics

    Cybernetics. Transactions of the Seventh Conference on Cybernetics. March 23–24, 1950. Heinz von Foerster, Ed. New York, the Josiah Macy, Jr. Foundation.

    Bibliographic record only

    Heinz von Foerster is named as editor, not sole author.

  5. Selected readings, 21 March 1952

    The Transmission of Information

    Fano, R. M. The Transmission of Information. M.I.T. Research Laboratory of Electronics. Technical Report No. 65. Part II. Technical Report No. 149.

    Selected primary passages reviewed

    Open the primary text or archive record · TR 65: abstract, introduction, and sections I–III; TR 149 not inspected

    One source entry names two reports, TR 65 and Part II/TR 149. The inspected full text is TR 65, dated 17 March 1949; TR 149 remains a separate research lead.

  6. Selected readings, 21 March 1952

    Science and Complexity

    Weaver, Warren. ‘Science and Complexity,’ American Scientist, Vol. 36, No. 4, 536–544.

    Bibliographic record only
  7. Selected readings, 21 March 1952

    Cybernetics: Or Control and Communication in the Animal and the Machine

    Wiener, Norbert. Cybernetics. Cambridge, Mass. Technology Press. 1948.

    Bibliographic record only
  8. Selected readings, 21 March 1952

    The Human Use of Human Beings

    Wiener, Norbert. The Human Use of Human Beings. Boston, 1950; London, Eyre and Spottiswoode.

    Bibliographic record only
  9. Short bibliography, described as 1956

    Design for a Brain

    Ashby, W. Ross, Design for a Brain, John Wiley & Sons, Inc., New York (Chapman & Hall, Ltd., London), 1952.

    Selected primary passages reviewed

    Open the primary text or archive record · 1954 corrected reprint: preface, 3/14, 8/4–8/7

  10. Short bibliography, described as 1956

    Information Theory and its Engineering Applications

    Bell, D. A., Information Theory and its Engineering Applications, Sir Isaac Pitman & Sons, London, 1953.

    Bibliographic record only
  11. Short bibliography, described as 1956

    Giant Brains, or Machines That Think

    Berkeley, E. C., Giant Brains, or Machines That Think, John Wiley & Sons, Inc., New York, 1949.

    Bibliographic record only
  12. Short bibliography, described as 1956

    Science and Information Theory

    Brillouin, L., Science and Information Theory, Academic Press, New York, 1956.

    Bibliographic record only
  13. Short bibliography, described as 1956

    La Cybernétique

    de Broglie, L., ‘La Cybernétique,’ report of Conference in Paris, 1951, published by Rev. opt. (165 rue de Sèvres, Paris).

    Bibliographic record only
  14. Short bibliography, described as 1956

    On Human Communication

    Cherry, C., On Human Communication, The Technology Press of M.I.T. & John Wiley & Sons, Inc., New York, (Chapman & Hall, Ltd., London), 1957.

    Bibliographic record only

    The list is described as 1956, but this item gives 1957. Preserve both dates; the typescript’s exact date needs archival verification.

  15. Short bibliography, described as 1956

    Conferences on Cybernetics: Transactions, Seventh to Tenth

    Conferences on Cybernetics, Transactions, 7th (1950) to 10th (1953), Josiah Macy Jr. Foundation, New York.

    Bibliographic record only

    A range of four conference volumes; overlaps the separately listed seventh conference, without being identical to it.

  16. Short bibliography, described as 1956

    Lectures on Communication Theory

    Gabor, D., Lectures on Communication Theory, published by M.I.T., Cambridge, Mass., 1951.

    Bibliographic record only
  17. Short bibliography, described as 1956

    Information Theory

    Goldman, S., Information Theory, Constable & Co., Ltd., London, 1953.

    Bibliographic record only
  18. Short bibliography, described as 1956

    The Organization of Behavior

    Hebb, D. O., The Organization of Behavior, John Wiley & Sons, Inc., New York, (Chapman & Hall, Ltd., London), 1949.

    Bibliographic record only
  19. Short bibliography, described as 1956

    Thinking by Machine

    de Latil, P., Thinking by Machine, Sidgwick & Jackson, London, 1956, translated from La Pensée Artificielle, Librairie Gallimard, Paris, 1953.

    Bibliographic record only
  20. Short bibliography, described as 1956

    Machine Translation of Languages

    Locke, W. N., and A. D. Booth, Machine Translation of Languages, The Technology Press, M.I.T., and John Wiley and Sons, Inc., New York, 1955.

    Bibliographic record only
  21. Short bibliography, described as 1956

    An Introduction to the Theory of Control

    Macmillan, R. H., An Introduction to the Theory of Control, Cambridge University Press, London, 1951.

    Bibliographic record only
  22. Short bibliography, described as 1956

    Methods of Operations Research

    Morse, P. M., and G. E. Kimball, Methods of Operations Research, John Wiley & Sons, Inc., New York, 1951.

    Bibliographic record only
  23. Short bibliography, described as 1956

    Proceedings of the Second London Symposium on Applications of Communication Theory

    Proceedings Second London Symposium on Applications of Communication Theory, London, 1952, Butterworth Scientific Publication, London, 1953.

    Bibliographic record only
  24. Short bibliography, described as 1956

    The Mathematical Theory of Communication

    Shannon, C. E., and W. Weaver, The Mathematical Theory of Communication, University of Illinois Press, Urbana, 1949; published earlier in Bell System Tech. J., 27, 1948, pp. 379 and 623.

    Selected primary passages reviewed

    Open the primary text or archive record · 1949 preface; Shannon pp. 3–5; Weaver pp. 95–99

  25. Short bibliography, described as 1956

    The Living Brain

    Walter, G., The Living Brain, Gerald Duckworth & Co., Ltd., London, 1953.

    Bibliographic record only
  26. Short bibliography, described as 1956

    Cybernetics: Or Control and Communication in the Animal and the Machine

    Wiener, N., Cybernetics, The Technology Press, M.I.T. and John Wiley & Sons, (Hermann et Cie., Paris), New York, 1948.

    Bibliographic record only
  27. Short bibliography, described as 1956

    The Human Use of Human Beings

    Wiener, N., The Human Use of Human Beings, The Houghton Mifflin Co., Boston, 1950 and Doubleday & Co., Inc., New York, 1954.

    Bibliographic record only

    1950 first publication and 1954 revision are retained under one work, without treating their texts as identical.

  28. Short bibliography, described as 1956

    Probability and Information Theory with Application to Radar

    Woodward, P. M., Probability and Information Theory with Application to Radar, Pergamon Press, Ltd., London, 1953.

    Bibliographic record only
  29. Popular treatments, approximately 1951

    Brain is a Machine (Newsweek)

    ‘Brain is a Machine,’ Newsweek, Nov. 15, 1948.

    Bibliographic record only
  30. Popular treatments, approximately 1951

    In Man’s Image

    ‘In Man’s Image,’ Time, Dec. 27, 1948.

    Bibliographic record only
  31. Popular treatments, approximately 1951

    Machine in Man’s Image

    ‘Machine in Man’s Image,’ Sat. Review, Jan. 8, 1949.

    Bibliographic record only
  32. Popular treatments, approximately 1951

    Brain is a Machine (Science Digest)

    ‘Brain is a Machine,’ Science Digest, Feb. 1949.

    Bibliographic record only
  33. Popular treatments, approximately 1951

    Machines that Think

    ‘Machines that Think,’ Business Week, Feb. 19, 1949.

    Bibliographic record only
  34. Popular treatments, approximately 1951

    Cybernetics, a New Discipline

    C. Eisenhart, ‘Cybernetics, a New Discipline,’ Science, Apr. 22, 1949.

    Bibliographic record only
  35. Popular treatments, approximately 1951

    Review of Cybernetics (J. B. Thurston)

    J. B. Thurston, Review of Cybernetics, The Sat. Rev., Apr. 23, 1949.

    Bibliographic record only
  36. Popular treatments, approximately 1951

    Instrumentation and Cybernetics

    J. D. Trimmer, ‘Instrumentation and Cybernetics,’ Scientific Monthly, Nov. 1949.

    Bibliographic record only
  37. Popular treatments, approximately 1951

    Thinking Machine

    ‘Thinking Machine,’ Time, Jan. 23, 1950.

    Bibliographic record only
  38. Popular treatments, approximately 1951

    Mind and/or Machine

    A. Standen, ‘Mind and/or Machine,’ Commonweal, May 27, 1950.

    Bibliographic record only
  39. Popular treatments, approximately 1951

    Review of The Human Use of Human Beings (Mark Starr)

    Mark Starr, Review of The Human Use of Human Beings, The Sat. Review, Aug. 19, 1950.

    Bibliographic record only
  40. Popular treatments, approximately 1951

    Mind in Matter

    Irwin Edman, ‘Mind in Matter,’ New Yorker, Oct. 14, 1950.

    Bibliographic record only
  41. Popular treatments, approximately 1951

    Feed back to Idiocy

    ‘Feed back to Idiocy,’ Time, Jan. 8, 1951.

    Bibliographic record only
  42. Popular treatments, approximately 1951

    Current Biography, March 1951 (unidentified entry)

    Current Biography, March 1951.

    Bibliographic record only

    No article title or author supplied. Retained as an unresolved issue reference, without an invented publication identity.

  43. Popular treatments, approximately 1951

    If Robots Run the Works

    ‘If Robots Run the Works,’ J. K. Lagemann, Nation’s Business, March 1951.

    Bibliographic record only
  44. Popular treatments by Wiener

    World of Robot Brains

    ‘World of Robot Brains,’ Science Digest, Sept. 1949.

    Bibliographic record only
  45. Popular treatments by Wiener

    Electric Brains with Feelings

    ‘Electric Brains with Feelings,’ Science Digest, Sept. 1949.

    Bibliographic record only
  46. Popular treatments by Wiener

    Too Big for Private Enterprise

    ‘Too Big for Private Enterprise,’ Nation, May 20, 1950.

    Bibliographic record only
  47. Popular treatments by Wiener

    Too Damn Close

    ‘Too Damn Close,’ Atlantic Monthly, July 1950.

    Selected primary passages reviewed

    Open the primary text or archive record · Sections 1 and 2

  48. Popular treatments by Wiener

    How U.S. Cities Can Prepare for Atomic War

    ‘How U.S. Cities Can Prepare for Atomic War,’ with Karl Deutsch, Giorgio de Santillana, etc., Life, Dec. 18, 1950.

    Bibliographic record only

    The source says “etc.” after named collaborators; this is not asserted to be a complete author list.

What a bibliography can show

A listed title establishes that a compiler selected a work. It can help locate a text, recognise an audience, or trace public reception. Claims about influence, agreement, authorship, or the meaning of a theory need evidence appropriate to that claim.

Follow How a reading list makes a field, or The message arrived. What happened?