{ "schema_version": "1.0", "canonical_url": "https://transduction.systems/entries/concept_emergence/", "release": "0.35", "citation": "Taylor, B. P. (2026). Emergence. The Necessary Tangle, release 0.35. https://transduction.systems/entries/concept_emergence/", "licence": "CC BY-SA 4.0 for original atlas text and data; linked works retain their own terms", "entry": { "id": "concept_emergence", "label": "Emergence", "entity_type": "concept", "description": "The appearance at one scale of properties, patterns or capacities not straightforwardly present at another scale, arising through interactions and organisation. It describes a relation across levels; it is not a hidden causal substance.", "aliases": [ "Emergent properties" ], "boundary_ring": "0", "inclusion_reason": "seed_corpus", "status": "accepted", "source_ids": [ "src_grammar_presentation_2022", "src_grammar_2ed_2025", "src_sfi_emergence_self_organisation_2022" ], "set_tags": [ "systems", "grammar_of_systems", "complexity", "core_cluster", "unfix-32", "release_0_18" ], "espoused_labels": [], "observed_clusters": [], "canonical_definition": "A relation across levels or scales in which a macro-property or pattern arises from interactions among lower-level components yet is not usefully reducible to a simple inventory of those components.", "valid_from": "", "valid_to": "", "external_ids": "{}", "geographies": [], "licence": "", "review_status": "research_pass_needs_editor", "reviewed_by": "", "reviewed_at": "", "x": -0.116338, "y": 0.192525, "canonical_id": "concept_emergence", "public_visibility": "public", "publication_level": "profile", "public_stub_text": "", "public_source_count": 3, "no_public_link_count": 0 }, "profile": { "node_id": "concept_emergence", "title": "Emergence", "profile_status": "evidence_deepened_research_pass", "canonical_definition": "A relation across levels or scales in which a macro-property or pattern arises from interactions among lower-level components yet is not usefully reducible to a simple inventory of those components.", "summary": "Emergence names a relation across levels: interactions among parts produce a pattern, property or capacity visible at another scale. It can mark genuine explanatory work, but the word becomes empty when used instead of specifying mechanisms and conditions.", "why_it_matters": "Complex outcomes cannot usually be attributed to one actor or intervention. Emergence helps resist linear claims of delivery and control. It does not mean outcomes are uncaused, magical or beyond all inquiry.", "key_distinctions": [ "cross-scale property vs self-organising process", "weak or epistemic emergence vs stronger ontological claims", "novel pattern vs surprise to an observer", "emergence vs aggregation", "description vs mechanism" ], "historical_lineage": [ "older philosophical whole-part debates", "general systems and cybernetics", "complexity science and scale-dependent pattern", "contemporary information-based accounts" ], "logical_antecedents": [ "components and interactions", "levels or scales of description", "nonlinear or combinatorial organisation", "observer and criteria of novelty" ], "dependent_subsequents": [ "complex adaptive systems", "multi-level explanation", "limits of prediction", "outcomes-as-emergent arguments" ], "practice_connections": [ "stop claiming to deliver outcomes produced by many interacting agents", "look for conditions and feedback rather than single causes", "state the scale at which the property appears", "use experiments and probes without pretending they command the whole" ], "espoused_lineages": [ "philosophy of science", "general systems", "cybernetics", "complexity science" ], "observed_clusters": [], "common_misreadings": [ "emergence is a force", "emergent means unpredictable", "calling something emergent explains it", "emergence guarantees novelty or improvement" ], "open_checks": [ "Lewes and historical terminology", "strong vs weak emergence", "causal emergence", "public-service outcome applications" ], "source_ids": [ "src_sfi_emergence_self_organisation_2022", "src_complexity_explorer_intro", "src_grammar_presentation_2022" ], "evidence_ids": [ "ev_sfi_emergence_self_organisation" ], "last_researched": "2026-08-09", "review_status": "research_pass_needs_editor", "editorial_note": "Readable orientation and evidence-backed first pass. Not accepted scholarly consensus until named review is recorded." }, "connections": [ { "id": "e16_grammar_crosswalk_082", "source": "law_or_principle_self_organised_criticality", "target": "concept_emergence", "relation_type": "explains", "relation_family": "conceptual", "directed": "true", "dependency_kind": "", "confidence": "0.76", "claim_status": "provisional", "source_ids": [ "src_grammar_presentation_2022", "src_grammar_2ed_2025", "src_salah_grammar_part2_2022" ], "evidence_ids": [], "source_locator": "Crosswalk from the maintained law description and cited Grammar sources to the target entry's maintained definition", "valid_from": "", "valid_to": "", "scope_conditions": "This is an interpretive conceptual crosswalk. It does not assert direct historical influence, formal equivalence or universal validity. The wording should be challenged or strengthened with page-level evidence.", "assertion_mode": "interpreted", "inference_method": "curator-requested semantic crosswalk of public descriptions", "claim_id": "", "reviewed_by": "", "reviewed_at": "", "notes": "", "plain_phrase": "describes one route to abrupt system-level", "public_review_label": "provisional conceptual crosswalk" }, { "id": "e16_grammar_crosswalk_106", "source": "law_or_principle_self_organising_principle", "target": "concept_emergence", "relation_type": "explains", "relation_family": "conceptual", "directed": "true", "dependency_kind": "", "confidence": "0.76", "claim_status": "provisional", "source_ids": [ "src_grammar_presentation_2022", "src_grammar_2ed_2025", "src_salah_grammar_part2_2022" ], "evidence_ids": [], "source_locator": "Crosswalk from the maintained law description and cited Grammar sources to the target entry's maintained definition", "valid_from": "", "valid_to": "", "scope_conditions": "This is an interpretive conceptual crosswalk. It does not assert direct historical influence, formal equivalence or universal validity. The wording should be challenged or strengthened with page-level evidence.", "assertion_mode": "interpreted", "inference_method": "curator-requested semantic crosswalk of public descriptions", "claim_id": "", "reviewed_by": "", "reviewed_at": "", "notes": "", "plain_phrase": "describes one process which may generate", "public_review_label": "provisional conceptual crosswalk" }, { "id": "e16_grammar_crosswalk_140", "source": "law_or_principle_law_of_sufficient_complexity", "target": "concept_emergence", "relation_type": "explains", "relation_family": "conceptual", "directed": "true", "dependency_kind": "", "confidence": "0.76", "claim_status": "provisional", "source_ids": [ "src_grammar_presentation_2022", "src_grammar_2ed_2025", "src_scio_grammar_case_multiple_disadvantage", "src_salah_grammar_part3_2022" ], "evidence_ids": [], "source_locator": "Crosswalk from the maintained law description and cited Grammar sources to the target entry's maintained definition", "valid_from": "", "valid_to": "", "scope_conditions": "This is an interpretive conceptual crosswalk. It does not assert direct historical influence, formal equivalence or universal validity. The wording should be challenged or strengthened with page-level evidence.", "assertion_mode": "interpreted", "inference_method": "curator-requested semantic crosswalk of public descriptions", "claim_id": "", "reviewed_by": "", "reviewed_at": "", "notes": "", "plain_phrase": "provides a structural reading of", "public_review_label": "provisional conceptual crosswalk" }, { "id": "e16_grammar_crosswalk_173", "source": "law_or_principle_principle_of_emergence", "target": "concept_emergence", "relation_type": "formalises", "relation_family": "conceptual", "directed": "true", "dependency_kind": "", "confidence": "0.76", "claim_status": "provisional", "source_ids": [ "src_grammar_presentation_2022", "src_grammar_2ed_2025", "src_salah_grammar_part3_2022" ], "evidence_ids": [], "source_locator": "Crosswalk from the maintained law description and cited Grammar sources to the target entry's maintained definition", "valid_from": "", "valid_to": "", "scope_conditions": "This is an interpretive conceptual crosswalk. It does not assert direct historical influence, formal equivalence or universal validity. The wording should be challenged or strengthened with page-level evidence.", "assertion_mode": "interpreted", "inference_method": "curator-requested semantic crosswalk of public descriptions", "claim_id": "", "reviewed_by": "", "reviewed_at": "", "notes": "", "plain_phrase": "offers a systems-law formulation of", "public_review_label": "provisional conceptual crosswalk" }, { "id": "e18_unfix32_emergence", "source": "publication_unfix_32_key_concepts", "target": "concept_emergence", "relation_type": "includes_in_synthesis", "relation_family": "classification", "directed": "true", "dependency_kind": "", "confidence": "0.94", "claim_status": "accepted", "source_ids": [ "src_unfix_32_key_concepts_2024" ], "evidence_ids": [], "source_locator": "Heading: Emergence", "valid_from": "", "valid_to": "", "scope_conditions": "This line records inclusion in Jurgen Appelo's named 32-concept synthesis. It does not endorse the definition, score or placement as a field consensus.", "assertion_mode": "asserted", "inference_method": "", "claim_id": "", "reviewed_by": "Benjamin P Taylor", "reviewed_at": "2026-08-19", "notes": "", "plain_phrase": "includes in its synthesis", "public_review_label": "source-backed statement" }, { "id": "e_0297", "source": "concept_recursion", "target": "concept_emergence", "relation_type": "legacy_association_unspecified", "relation_family": "legacy", "directed": "false", "dependency_kind": "", "confidence": "0.4", "claim_status": "legacy_unverified", "source_ids": [ "src_sysbok_recursion_2013" ], "evidence_ids": [], "source_locator": "", "valid_from": "", "valid_to": "", "scope_conditions": "", "assertion_mode": "inherited", "inference_method": "", "claim_id": "", "reviewed_by": "", "reviewed_at": "", "notes": "Legacy relation 'conceptually_related_to' retained for audit; semantics unresolved or invalid. | Legacy relation 'legacy_association_unspecified' retained for audit; semantics unresolved or invalid. | Legacy relation 'legacy_association_unspecified' retained for audit; semantics unresolved or invalid. | Legacy relation 'legacy_association_unspecified' retained for audit; semantics unresolved or invalid. | Legacy relation 'legacy_association_unspecified' retained for audit; semantics unresolved or invalid. | Legacy relation 'legacy_association_unspecified' retained for audit; semantics unresolved or invalid. | Legacy relation 'legacy_association_unspecified' retained for audit; semantics unresolved or invalid. | Legacy relation 'legacy_association_unspecified' retained for audit; semantics unresolved or invalid.", "plain_phrase": "was linked in an inherited map, but the meaning of the link is unresolved", "public_review_label": "legacy_unverified" }, { "id": "e_07_principia_01", "source": "concept_metasystem_transition", "target": "concept_emergence", "relation_type": "specialises", "relation_family": "conceptual", "directed": "true", "dependency_kind": "", "confidence": "0.92", "claim_status": "accepted", "source_ids": [ "src_principia_mstt", "src_principia_nutshell" ], "evidence_ids": [], "source_locator": "Metasystem Transition Theory, opening definition and examples; Principia in a Nutshell, Metasystem Transition Theory section", "valid_from": "", "valid_to": "", "scope_conditions": "The project describes a metasystem transition as the emergence of a higher level of control. This is Principia's technical specialisation of emergence, not a synonym for every emergent phenomenon.", "assertion_mode": "asserted", "inference_method": "close reading of two project-authored internal theory pages", "claim_id": "", "reviewed_by": "Benjamin P Taylor", "reviewed_at": "2026-08-10", "notes": "A metasystem transition is presented as the formation of a higher-level system that controls lower-level systems; the edge now states that specific cross-scale claim.", "plain_phrase": "specialises emergence as a new higher level of control within", "public_review_label": "source-established project definition" }, { "id": "e_09_complex_responsive_emergence", "source": "tradition_complex_responsive_processes", "target": "concept_emergence", "relation_type": "explains", "relation_family": "conceptual", "directed": "true", "dependency_kind": "", "confidence": "0.83", "claim_status": "provisional", "source_ids": [ "src_stacey_emergence_knowledge_2000", "src_stacey_complex_responsive_processes_2001" ], "evidence_ids": [], "source_locator": "University of Hertfordshire record, abstract; Emergence 2(4), pp. 23–39", "valid_from": "", "valid_to": "", "scope_conditions": "This is an account of emergent organisational knowledge through interaction, not a general theory of every form of emergence.", "assertion_mode": "interpreted", "inference_method": "close reading of the institutional abstract and bibliographic comparison with the book", "claim_id": "", "reviewed_by": "Benjamin P Taylor", "reviewed_at": "2026-08-10", "notes": "Stacey's abstract describes knowledge as continuously reproduced and potentially transformed in interaction; the edge interprets that as a specific organisational account of emergence.", "plain_phrase": "explains the emergence of organisational knowledge through", "public_review_label": "interpreted from author abstract" }, { "id": "e_fpcs_topic_029_concept_emergence", "source": "concept_emergence", "target": "publication_fpcs_029", "relation_type": "described_by", "relation_family": "evidence", "directed": "true", "dependency_kind": "", "confidence": "0.65", "claim_status": "provisional", "source_ids": [ "src_fpcs_official_toc" ], "evidence_ids": [], "source_locator": "", "valid_from": "", "valid_to": "", "scope_conditions": "A cautious first-pass topic link based on the paper title and collection placement; substantive review remains pending.", "assertion_mode": "asserted", "inference_method": "", "claim_id": "", "reviewed_by": "Benjamin P Taylor", "reviewed_at": "2026-08-10", "notes": "A cautious first-pass topic link based on the paper title and collection placement; substantive review remains pending. Candidate relation retained after endpoint and source validation.", "plain_phrase": "has a foundational treatment in", "public_review_label": "provisional" }, { "id": "e_fpcs_topic_039_concept_emergence", "source": "concept_emergence", "target": "publication_fpcs_039", "relation_type": "described_by", "relation_family": "evidence", "directed": "true", "dependency_kind": "", "confidence": "0.65", "claim_status": "provisional", "source_ids": [ "src_fpcs_official_toc" ], "evidence_ids": [], "source_locator": "", "valid_from": "", "valid_to": "", "scope_conditions": "A cautious first-pass topic link based on the paper title and collection placement; substantive review remains pending.", "assertion_mode": "asserted", "inference_method": "", "claim_id": "", "reviewed_by": "Benjamin P Taylor", "reviewed_at": "2026-08-10", "notes": "A cautious first-pass topic link based on the paper title and collection placement; substantive review remains pending. Candidate relation retained after endpoint and source validation.", "plain_phrase": "has a foundational treatment in", "public_review_label": "provisional" }, { "id": "e_fpcs_topic_078_concept_emergence", "source": "concept_emergence", "target": "publication_fpcs_078", "relation_type": "described_by", "relation_family": "evidence", "directed": "true", "dependency_kind": "", "confidence": "0.65", "claim_status": "provisional", "source_ids": [ "src_fpcs_official_toc" ], "evidence_ids": [], "source_locator": "", "valid_from": "", "valid_to": "", "scope_conditions": "A cautious first-pass topic link based on the paper title and collection placement; substantive review remains pending.", "assertion_mode": "asserted", "inference_method": "", "claim_id": "", "reviewed_by": "Benjamin P Taylor", "reviewed_at": "2026-08-10", "notes": "A cautious first-pass topic link based on the paper title and collection placement; substantive review remains pending. Candidate relation retained after endpoint and source validation.", "plain_phrase": "has a foundational treatment in", "public_review_label": "provisional" }, { "id": "e_overnight_sfi_emergence_complexity", "source": "concept_emergence", "target": "concept_complexity", "relation_type": "explains", "relation_family": "conceptual", "directed": "true", "dependency_kind": "", "confidence": "0.82", "claim_status": "provisional", "source_ids": [ "src_sfi_complexity_about", "src_complexity_explorer_intro" ], "evidence_ids": [], "source_locator": "SFI About, section 'What is Complex Systems Science?'; Complexity Explorer syllabus, units 1-10", "valid_from": "", "valid_to": "", "scope_conditions": "SFI presents surprising emergent macro behaviour as a recurring feature of interacting adaptive agents; complexity is broader than emergence and not every complex system exhibits the same form.", "assertion_mode": "interpreted", "inference_method": "interpretive synthesis of two official SFI scope statements", "claim_id": "", "reviewed_by": "Benjamin P Taylor", "reviewed_at": "2026-08-14", "notes": "The edge records SFI's cross-scale framing while avoiding the stronger and unsupported claim that emergence defines all complexity.", "plain_phrase": "characterises macro-level behaviour studied within", "public_review_label": "interpreted institutional framing" }, { "id": "e_v03_emergence_observer", "source": "concept_emergence", "target": "concept_observer", "relation_type": "uses", "relation_family": "practice", "directed": "true", "dependency_kind": "", "confidence": "0.65", "claim_status": "provisional", "source_ids": [ "src_sep_emergent_properties_2022", "src_taylor_core_thinking_2026" ], "evidence_ids": [ "ev_sep_emergence_dependence_autonomy", "ev_taylor_core_distinctions_boundaries" ], "source_locator": "SEP emergence overview; Core Thinking Integration observer section", "valid_from": "", "valid_to": "", "scope_conditions": "", "assertion_mode": "asserted", "inference_method": "editorial synthesis from cited evidence", "claim_id": "", "reviewed_by": "", "reviewed_at": "", "notes": "", "plain_phrase": "uses", "public_review_label": "provisional" }, { "id": "e_v03_emergence_self_org_confused", "source": "concept_emergence", "target": "concept_self_organisation", "relation_type": "often_confused_with", "relation_family": "contestation", "directed": "false", "dependency_kind": "", "confidence": "0.9", "claim_status": "corroborated", "source_ids": [ "src_sfi_emergence_self_organisation_2022" ], "evidence_ids": [ "ev_sfi_emergence_self_organisation" ], "source_locator": "Seminar abstract", "valid_from": "", "valid_to": "", "scope_conditions": "", "assertion_mode": "editorial_research_pass", "inference_method": "source_comparison", "claim_id": "", "reviewed_by": "", "reviewed_at": "", "notes": "They may co-occur, but one concerns cross-scale properties and the other the process by which order arises through local interaction.", "plain_phrase": "is often confused with", "public_review_label": "supported" }, { "id": "e16_relational_crosswalk_029", "source": "intervention_skill_culture_mapping", "target": "concept_emergence", "relation_type": "applies", "relation_family": "practice", "directed": "true", "dependency_kind": "", "confidence": "0.72", "claim_status": "provisional", "source_ids": [ "src_scio_cf_resources_2022", "src_scio_accreditation_current", "src_grammar_presentation_2022", "src_grammar_2ed_2025", "src_sfi_emergence_self_organisation_2022" ], "evidence_ids": [], "source_locator": "Interpretive comparison of the two maintained public descriptions and their cited source records", "valid_from": "", "valid_to": "", "scope_conditions": "This is a provisional semantic or practice crosswalk. It does not establish historical influence, equivalence, efficacy or universal applicability. Item-level source review and curator acceptance are still required.", "assertion_mode": "interpreted", "inference_method": "curator-requested relational crosswalk of maintained public descriptions", "claim_id": "", "reviewed_by": "", "reviewed_at": "", "notes": "", "plain_phrase": "examines interaction-level conditions for", "public_review_label": "provisional relational crosswalk" }, { "id": "e16_relational_crosswalk_154", "source": "method_or_methodology_agent_based_modelling", "target": "concept_emergence", "relation_type": "uses", "relation_family": "practice", "directed": "true", "dependency_kind": "", "confidence": "0.72", "claim_status": "provisional", "source_ids": [ "src_complexity_explorer_intro", "src_damian_lineage_diagram_2026", "src_grammar_presentation_2022", "src_grammar_2ed_2025", "src_sfi_emergence_self_organisation_2022" ], "evidence_ids": [], "source_locator": "Interpretive comparison of the two maintained public descriptions and their cited source records", "valid_from": "", "valid_to": "", "scope_conditions": "This is a provisional semantic or practice crosswalk. It does not establish historical influence, equivalence, efficacy or universal applicability. Item-level source review and curator acceptance are still required.", "assertion_mode": "interpreted", "inference_method": "curator-requested relational crosswalk of maintained public descriptions", "claim_id": "", "reviewed_by": "", "reviewed_at": "", "notes": "", "plain_phrase": "explores the production of", "public_review_label": "provisional relational crosswalk" }, { "id": "e16_relational_crosswalk_158", "source": "method_or_methodology_bubble_strategy", "target": "concept_emergence", "relation_type": "uses", "relation_family": "practice", "directed": "true", "dependency_kind": "", "confidence": "0.72", "claim_status": "provisional", "source_ids": [ "src_scio_cf_resources_2022", "src_scio_bubble_2007", "src_grammar_presentation_2022", "src_grammar_2ed_2025", "src_sfi_emergence_self_organisation_2022" ], "evidence_ids": [], "source_locator": "Interpretive comparison of the two maintained public descriptions and their cited source records", "valid_from": "", "valid_to": "", "scope_conditions": "This is a provisional semantic or practice crosswalk. It does not establish historical influence, equivalence, efficacy or universal applicability. Item-level source review and curator acceptance are still required.", "assertion_mode": "interpreted", "inference_method": "curator-requested relational crosswalk of maintained public descriptions", "claim_id": "", "reviewed_by": "", "reviewed_at": "", "notes": "", "plain_phrase": "allows new practice to develop through", "public_review_label": "provisional relational crosswalk" }, { "id": "e16_relational_crosswalk_274", "source": "concept_global_brain", "target": "concept_emergence", "relation_type": "explains", "relation_family": "conceptual", "directed": "true", "dependency_kind": "", "confidence": "0.72", "claim_status": "provisional", "source_ids": [ "src_principia_global_brain", "src_principia_intro", "src_grammar_presentation_2022", "src_grammar_2ed_2025", "src_sfi_emergence_self_organisation_2022" ], "evidence_ids": [], "source_locator": "Interpretive comparison of the two maintained public descriptions and their cited source records", "valid_from": "", "valid_to": "", "scope_conditions": "This is a provisional semantic or practice crosswalk. It does not establish historical influence, equivalence, efficacy or universal applicability. Item-level source review and curator acceptance are still required.", "assertion_mode": "interpreted", "inference_method": "curator-requested relational crosswalk of maintained public descriptions", "claim_id": "", "reviewed_by": "", "reviewed_at": "", "notes": "", "plain_phrase": "is proposed as a large-scale form of", "public_review_label": "provisional relational crosswalk" }, { "id": "e26_a1af0f50ac328f0487934a", "source": "resource_sp26_f455a61e7d99311f", "target": "concept_emergence", "relation_type": "source_text_mentions", "relation_family": "documentary", "directed": "true", "dependency_kind": "", "confidence": "", "claim_status": "candidate", "source_ids": [ "src_sp26_f455a61e7d99311f" ], "evidence_ids": [], "source_locator": "Extracted source text, character 290800; page-level locator pending", "valid_from": "", "valid_to": "", "scope_conditions": "Exact phrase in extracted source text; page-level checking may remain pending as recorded by the locator. Its appearance may be in discussion, a quotation, a reference, or a critical comparison. No semantic or historical claim is inferred.", "assertion_mode": "asserted", "inference_method": "", "claim_id": "", "reviewed_by": "", "reviewed_at": "", "notes": "", "plain_phrase": "contains a located mention of Emergent properties", "public_review_label": "Located source statement; independent review not recorded", "connection_pass": "library_20260919" }, { "id": "e26_49616c83d3807ff20eee1a", "source": "resource_sp26_a7bf870141f1233d", "target": "concept_emergence", "relation_type": "source_text_mentions", "relation_family": "documentary", "directed": "true", "dependency_kind": "", "confidence": "", "claim_status": "candidate", "source_ids": [ "src_sp26_a7bf870141f1233d" ], "evidence_ids": [], "source_locator": "Extracted source text, character 12873; page-level locator pending", "valid_from": "", "valid_to": "", "scope_conditions": "Exact phrase in extracted source text; page-level checking may remain pending as recorded by the locator. Its appearance may be in discussion, a quotation, a reference, or a critical comparison. No semantic or historical claim is inferred.", "assertion_mode": "asserted", "inference_method": "", "claim_id": "", "reviewed_by": "", "reviewed_at": "", "notes": "", "plain_phrase": "contains a located mention of Emergent properties", "public_review_label": "Located source statement; independent review not recorded", "connection_pass": "library_20260919" }, { "id": "e26_046c74eebcefe1986d1b4b", "source": "resource_sp26_a63f52d3fe0bc7c0", "target": "concept_emergence", "relation_type": "source_text_mentions", "relation_family": "documentary", "directed": "true", "dependency_kind": "", "confidence": "", "claim_status": "candidate", "source_ids": [ "src_sp26_a63f52d3fe0bc7c0" ], "evidence_ids": [], "source_locator": "Extracted source text, character 256745; page-level locator pending", "valid_from": "", "valid_to": "", "scope_conditions": "Exact phrase in extracted source text; page-level checking may remain pending as recorded by the locator. Its appearance may be in discussion, a quotation, a reference, or a critical comparison. No semantic or historical claim is inferred.", "assertion_mode": "asserted", "inference_method": "", "claim_id": "", "reviewed_by": "", "reviewed_at": "", "notes": "", "plain_phrase": "contains a located mention of Emergent properties", "public_review_label": "Located source statement; independent review not recorded", "connection_pass": "library_20260919" }, { "id": "e26_0f8e7a7718daab1c2be492", "source": "resource_sp26_70ea58555bf5f8be", "target": "concept_emergence", "relation_type": "source_text_mentions", "relation_family": "documentary", "directed": "true", "dependency_kind": "", "confidence": "", "claim_status": "candidate", "source_ids": [ "src_sp26_70ea58555bf5f8be" ], "evidence_ids": [], "source_locator": "Extracted source text, character 15612; page-level locator pending", "valid_from": "", "valid_to": "", "scope_conditions": "Exact phrase in extracted source text; page-level checking may remain pending as recorded by the locator. Its appearance may be in discussion, a quotation, a reference, or a critical comparison. No semantic or historical claim is inferred.", "assertion_mode": "asserted", "inference_method": "", "claim_id": "", "reviewed_by": "", "reviewed_at": "", "notes": "", "plain_phrase": "contains a located mention of Emergent properties", "public_review_label": "Located source statement; independent review not recorded", "connection_pass": "library_20260919" }, { "id": "e26_69e09972c8dcbe9fcbc633", "source": "resource_sp26_2b9130787f8b4a27", "target": "concept_emergence", "relation_type": "source_text_mentions", "relation_family": "documentary", "directed": "true", "dependency_kind": "", "confidence": "", "claim_status": "candidate", "source_ids": [ "src_sp26_2b9130787f8b4a27" ], "evidence_ids": [], "source_locator": "Extracted source text, character 33781; page-level locator pending", "valid_from": "", "valid_to": "", "scope_conditions": "Exact phrase in extracted source text; page-level checking may remain pending as recorded by the locator. Its appearance may be in discussion, a quotation, a reference, or a critical comparison. No semantic or historical claim is inferred.", "assertion_mode": "asserted", "inference_method": "", "claim_id": "", "reviewed_by": "", "reviewed_at": "", "notes": "", "plain_phrase": "contains a located mention of Emergent properties", "public_review_label": "Located source statement; independent review not recorded", "connection_pass": "library_20260919" }, { "id": "e31_module_bhaskar_3", "source": "publication_u31_bhaskar", "target": "concept_emergence", "relation_type": "presents_account_of", "relation_family": "conceptual", "directed": "true", "dependency_kind": "", "confidence": "", "claim_status": "candidate", "source_ids": [ "src_u31_bhaskar" ], "evidence_ids": [ "ev_e31_module_bhaskar_3" ], "source_locator": "p. 4, PG4", "valid_from": "", "valid_to": "", "scope_conditions": "In Challoner’s reconstruction: Emergent powers depend on underlying organisation without being reduced to it.", "assertion_mode": "asserted", "inference_method": "", "claim_id": "claim_e31_module_bhaskar_3", "reviewed_by": "", "reviewed_at": "", "notes": "", "plain_phrase": "presents account of", "public_review_label": "Located source statement; curator review pending", "connection_pass": "update_20261008" } ], "claims": [ { "id": "claim_outcomes_conditions_not_delivery", "statement": "For outcomes produced by complex adaptive systems, a public service contributes conditions and affordances rather than controlling or delivering the whole result.", "subject_id": "concept_emergence", "predicate": "constrains", "object_id": "concept_purpose", "status": "provisional", "supporting_source_ids": [ "src_taylor_outcomes_complexity_2025", "src_sep_emergent_properties_2022" ], "supporting_evidence_ids": [ "ev_taylor_outcomes_conditions", "ev_sep_emergence_dependence_autonomy" ], "contradicting_source_ids": [], "contradicting_evidence_ids": [], "notes": "Scope is deliberately narrow. Named editorial review is required.", "review_status": "research_pass_needs_editor", "reviewed_by": "", "reviewed_at": "" }, { "id": "claim_v03_emergence_not_mechanism", "statement": "Emergence describes a cross-scale relation or explanatory problem; naming a property emergent does not by itself identify the mechanism that produced it.", "subject_id": "concept_emergence", "predicate": "distinguishes", "object_id": "concept_self_organisation", "status": "provisional", "supporting_source_ids": [ "src_sfi_emergence_self_organisation_2022" ], "supporting_evidence_ids": [ "ev_sfi_emergence_self_organisation" ], "contradicting_source_ids": [], "contradicting_evidence_ids": [], "notes": "Editorial interpretation supported by the source distinction, requiring human review.", "review_status": "research_pass_needs_editor", "reviewed_by": "", "reviewed_at": "" }, { "id": "claim_e31_module_bhaskar_3", "statement": "In Challoner’s reconstruction: Emergent powers depend on underlying organisation without being reduced to it.", "subject_id": "publication_u31_bhaskar", "predicate": "presents_account_of", "object_id": "concept_emergence", "status": "candidate", "supporting_source_ids": [ "src_u31_bhaskar" ], "supporting_evidence_ids": [ "ev_e31_module_bhaskar_3" ], "contradicting_source_ids": [], "contradicting_evidence_ids": [], "notes": "Source-scoped interpretation. Human editorial acceptance remains pending.", "review_status": "research_pass_needs_editor", "reviewed_by": "", "reviewed_at": "", "connection_pass": "update_20261008" } ], "sources": [ { "id": "src_grammar_presentation_2022", "title": "The Grammar of Systems - SCiO presentation", "source_type": "presentation", "quality_tier": "C", "access": "public", "url": "https://www.systemspractice.org/resources/grammar-systems", "date": "2022-03-21", "notes": "Lists 33 systems laws and principles and describes nine patterns of thinking.", "creators": [ "Patrick Hoverstadt" ], "doi": "", "isbn": "", "publisher": "SCiO", "licence": "site_terms", "archived_url": "", "content_hash": "", "review_status": "checked", "last_checked": "2026-08-10", "public_link_status": "public_link" }, { "id": "src_grammar_2ed_2025", "title": "The Grammar of Systems II: From Order to Chaos and Back Again, 2nd edition", "source_type": "book", "quality_tier": "B", "access": "public_metadata", "url": "https://www.systemspractice.org/resources/grammar-systems-ii-order-chaos-back-again-2nd-ed", "date": "2025-08-01", "notes": "Current second-edition metadata. The book presents nine systems-thinking patterns and 33 systems laws and principles.", "creators": [ "Patrick Hoverstadt" ], "doi": "", "isbn": "979-8298960878", "publisher": "SCiO", "licence": "publisher_terms", "archived_url": "", "content_hash": "", "review_status": "checked", "last_checked": "2026-08-10", "public_link_status": "public_link" }, { "id": "src_sfi_emergence_self_organisation_2022", "title": "Emergence, (Self)Organization, and Complexity", "source_type": "research_institute_seminar_abstract", "quality_tier": "B", "access": "public", "url": "https://web-prod.santafe.edu/events/emergence-selforganization-and-complexity", "date": "2022-10-26", "notes": "Santa Fe Institute seminar abstract distinguishing emergence across scales from self-organisation through local interaction without central control.", "creators": [ "Carlos Gershenson", "Santa Fe Institute" ], "doi": "", "isbn": "", "publisher": "Santa Fe Institute", "licence": "site_terms", "archived_url": "", "content_hash": "", "review_status": "research_pass_needs_editor", "last_checked": "2026-08-09", "public_link_status": "public_link" }, { "id": "src_complexity_explorer_intro", "title": "Introduction to Complexity (Santa Fe Institute Complexity Explorer)", "source_type": "research_institute_course", "quality_tier": "B", "access": "public", "url": "https://www.complexityexplorer.org/courses/185-introduction-to-complexity", "date": "2026-08-09", "notes": "Official ten-unit syllabus covering dynamics, chaos, information, self-organisation, agent-based modelling, networks and scaling. Used for curriculum coverage, not proof that the curriculum exhausts complexity science.", "creators": [], "doi": "", "isbn": "", "publisher": "Santa Fe Institute Complexity Explorer", "licence": "", "archived_url": "", "content_hash": "", "review_status": "checked_internal_syllabus", "last_checked": "2026-08-14", "public_link_status": "public_link" }, { "id": "src_salah_grammar_part2_2022", "title": "Cybersecurity Lessons from The Grammar of Systems, part 2", "source_type": "public_secondary_summary", "quality_tier": "C", "access": "public", "url": "https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/cybersecurity-lessons-from-grammar-systems-order-chaos-osama-salah-1f", "date": "2022-05-23", "notes": "Public secondary summary of Grammar of Systems items 12–22. Used as an accessible orientation aid; the book remains the controlling source.", "creators": [ "Osama Salah" ], "publisher": "LinkedIn", "licence": "publisher_terms", "review_status": "checked", "last_checked": "2026-08-09", "public_link_status": "public_link" }, { "id": "src_scio_grammar_case_multiple_disadvantage", "title": "Applying insight from Systems Laws to challenge thinking on, and service design for, the Multiple Disadvantage system", "source_type": "professional_case_study", "quality_tier": "C", "access": "public", "url": "https://www.systemspractice.org/resources/applying-insight-systems-laws-challenge-thinking-and-service-design-multiple-disadvantage", "date": "2026-01-01", "notes": "Public SCiO case illustrating the Law of Calling, Law of Sufficient Complexity and Conant-Ashby Theorem in practice.", "creators": [], "doi": "", "isbn": "", "publisher": "SCiO", "licence": "site_terms", "archived_url": "", "content_hash": "", "review_status": "checked", "last_checked": "2026-08-09", "public_link_status": "public_link" }, { "id": "src_salah_grammar_part3_2022", "title": "Cybersecurity Lessons from The Grammar of Systems, part 3", "source_type": "public_secondary_summary", "quality_tier": "C", "access": "public", "url": "https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/cybersecurity-lessons-from-grammar-systems-order-chaos-osama-salah-2f", "date": "2022-06-01", "notes": "Public secondary summary of Grammar of Systems items 23–33. Used as an accessible orientation aid; the book remains the controlling source.", "creators": [ "Osama Salah" ], "publisher": "LinkedIn", "licence": "publisher_terms", "review_status": "checked", "last_checked": "2026-08-09", "public_link_status": "public_link" }, { "id": "src_unfix_32_key_concepts_2024", "title": "32 Key Concepts in Systems Thinking and Complexity Theory", "source_type": "first_party_synthesis", "quality_tier": "B", "access": "public", "url": "https://unfix.com/blog/32-key-concepts", "date": "2024-07-15", "notes": "Jurgen Appelo's unFIX synthesis of 32 concepts. The page states that the list and prevalence scores were generated with several large language models and checked against the author's experience; it is a useful comparator, not a neutral or exhaustive canon.", "creators": [ "Jurgen Appelo" ], "doi": "", "isbn": "", "publisher": "unFIX", "licence": "source terms unless otherwise stated", "archived_url": "", "content_hash": "", "review_status": "checked", "last_checked": "2026-08-19", "public_link_status": "public_link" }, { "id": "src_sysbok_recursion_2013", "title": "SCiO SysBoK - Recursion v1", "source_type": "legacy_map_presentation", "quality_tier": "C", "access": "no_public_link", "url": "", "date": "2013-07-01", "notes": "Legacy SCiO SysBoK working presentation; no public link.", "creators": [ "SCiO" ], "doi": "", "isbn": "", "publisher": "", "licence": "", "archived_url": "", "content_hash": "", "review_status": "pass4_legacy_internal_register_audit", "last_checked": "2026-08-14", "public_link_status": "no_public_link" }, { "id": "src_principia_mstt", "title": "Principia Cybernetica: Metasystem Transition Theory", "source_type": "official_project_theory_page", "quality_tier": "B", "access": "public", "url": "https://pespmc1.vub.ac.be/MSTT.html", "date": "", "notes": "Official project account of metasystem transition theory and its attribution to work by Valentin Turchin, Cliff Joslyn and Francis Heylighen.", "creators": [ "Principia Cybernetica Project editors" ], "doi": "", "isbn": "", "publisher": "Principia Cybernetica Project", "licence": "source_terms", "archived_url": "", "content_hash": "", "review_status": "checked_primary_register", "last_checked": "2026-08-09", "public_link_status": "public_link" }, { "id": "src_principia_nutshell", "title": "Principia Cybernetica in a Nutshell", "source_type": "primary_project_overview", "quality_tier": "B", "access": "public", "url": "https://pespmc1.vub.ac.be/NUTSHELL.html", "date": "", "notes": "Project overview covering typed nodes and links, constructivist epistemology, metasystem transitions and the intended semantic-network architecture.", "creators": [ "Principia Cybernetica Project editors" ], "doi": "", "isbn": "", "publisher": "Principia Cybernetica Project", "licence": "source_terms", "archived_url": "", "content_hash": "", "review_status": "checked_internal_page", "last_checked": "2026-08-14", "public_link_status": "public_link" }, { "id": "src_stacey_emergence_knowledge_2000", "title": "The emergence of knowledge in organisations", "source_type": "institutional_research_record", "quality_tier": "A", "access": "public", "url": "https://researchprofiles.herts.ac.uk/en/publications/the-emergence-of-knowledge-in-organisations/", "date": "2000", "notes": "University of Hertfordshire research record and abstract for Stacey's peer-reviewed article. The abstract presents complex responsive processes as an account of knowledge continuously reproduced and potentially transformed in interaction.", "creators": [ "Ralph D. Stacey" ], "doi": "10.1207/S15327000EM0204_05", "isbn": "", "publisher": "University of Hertfordshire / Emergence", "licence": "source_terms", "archived_url": "", "content_hash": "", "review_status": "checked_primary_institutional_record", "last_checked": "2026-08-14", "public_link_status": "public_link" }, { "id": "src_stacey_complex_responsive_processes_2001", "title": "Complex Responsive Processes in Organizations: Learning and Knowledge Creation", "source_type": "publisher_book_page", "quality_tier": "B", "access": "public_metadata", "url": "https://www.routledge.com/Complex-Responsive-Processes-in-Organizations-Learning-and-Knowledge-Creation/Stacey/p/book/9780415249195", "date": "2001", "notes": "Publisher record for Ralph Stacey's book introducing complex responsive processes of relating as an alternative to information-processing accounts of organisational knowledge.", "creators": [ "Ralph D. Stacey" ], "doi": "", "isbn": "9780415249195", "publisher": "Routledge", "licence": "publisher_terms", "archived_url": "", "content_hash": "", "review_status": "checked", "last_checked": "2026-08-10", "public_link_status": "public_link" }, { "id": "src_fpcs_official_toc", "title": "Foundational Papers in Complexity Science — official tables of contents", "source_type": "publisher_table_of_contents", "quality_tier": "A", "access": "public", "url": "https://www.foundationalpapersincomplexityscience.org/tables-of-contents", "date": "2024", "notes": "Official item-level contents for the four-volume Santa Fe Institute Press collection. It supports the bibliographic inventory, not the substantive claims of all 89 original papers.", "creators": [ "Santa Fe Institute Press", "David C. Krakauer (editor)" ], "publisher": "Santa Fe Institute Press", "licence": "source_terms", "review_status": "checked_primary_register", "last_checked": "2026-08-09", "public_link_status": "public_link", "doi": "", "isbn": "", "archived_url": "", "content_hash": "" }, { "id": "src_sfi_complexity_about", "title": "What is Complex Systems Science?", "source_type": "research_institute_self_description", "quality_tier": "B", "access": "public", "url": "https://www.santafe.edu/about", "date": "", "notes": "SFI institutional account of interacting and adapting agents, evolutionary processes and emergent macro behaviour across domains. Canonical for SFI's scope, not the whole field's consensus.", "creators": [ "Santa Fe Institute" ], "doi": "", "isbn": "", "publisher": "Santa Fe Institute", "licence": "source_terms", "archived_url": "", "content_hash": "", "review_status": "checked_institutional_scope", "last_checked": "2026-08-14", "public_link_status": "public_link" }, { "id": "src_sep_emergent_properties_2022", "title": "Emergent Properties", "source_type": "scholarly_encyclopaedia", "quality_tier": "A", "access": "public", "url": "https://plato.stanford.edu/archives/spr2022/entries/properties-emergent/", "date": "2022-01-01", "notes": "Scholarly overview of emergence, including dependence, autonomy and weak versus strong claims.", "creators": [ "Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy" ], "doi": "", "isbn": "", "publisher": "Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy", "licence": "site_terms", "archived_url": "", "content_hash": "", "review_status": "research_pass_needs_editor", "last_checked": "2026-08-09", "public_link_status": "public_link" }, { "id": "src_taylor_core_thinking_2026", "title": "Core Thinking Integration", "source_type": "unpublished_working_synthesis", "quality_tier": "C", "access": "no_public_link", "url": "", "date": "2026-08-09", "notes": "Unpublished working synthesis; no public link.", "creators": [ "Benjamin P Taylor" ], "doi": "", "isbn": "", "publisher": "Unpublished author material", "licence": "not_publicly_licensed", "archived_url": "", "content_hash": "", "review_status": "pass4_prior_material_register_review", "last_checked": "2026-08-14", "public_link_status": "no_public_link" }, { "id": "src_scio_cf_resources_2022", "title": "SCiO CF Resources v9 draft", "source_type": "professional_framework_resource_guide", "quality_tier": "C", "access": "no_public_link", "url": "", "date": "2022-09-15", "notes": "SCiO internal competency-resource draft; no public link. Public SCiO accreditation pages are linked separately where possible.", "creators": [ "SCiO" ], "doi": "", "isbn": "", "publisher": "", "licence": "", "archived_url": "", "content_hash": "", "review_status": "pass4_legacy_internal_register_audit", "last_checked": "2026-08-14", "public_link_status": "no_public_link" }, { "id": "src_scio_accreditation_current", "title": "SCiO Professional Accreditation and Competency Framework", "source_type": "professional_body_page", "quality_tier": "C", "access": "public", "url": "https://www.systemspractice.org/professional-accreditation", "date": "2026-08-09", "notes": "Current framework fields and assessment process.", "creators": [], "doi": "", "isbn": "", "publisher": "", "licence": "", "archived_url": "", "content_hash": "", "review_status": "checked", "last_checked": "2026-08-09", "public_link_status": "public_link" }, { "id": "src_damian_lineage_diagram_2026", "title": "Lineages of Systems Practice — Damian Allen", "source_type": "private_practitioner_lineage_diagram", "quality_tier": "A", "access": "private", "url": "", "date": "2026-05", "notes": "Authorized private research source. Public metadata is paraphrased; message identifiers, addresses, private URLs and unnecessary extracts are omitted. This is a first-person lineage claim, not independent proof of influence.", "creators": [ "Damian Allen" ], "doi": "", "isbn": "", "publisher": "", "licence": "", "archived_url": "", "content_hash": "", "review_status": "checked_for_doncaster_lineage", "last_checked": "2026-08-15", "public_link_status": "no_public_link" }, { "id": "src_scio_bubble_2007", "title": "The bubble strategy: A case study of dynamic, defensible processes of change in Salford", "source_type": "research_article_metadata", "quality_tier": "B", "access": "public_metadata", "url": "https://www.systemspractice.org/resources/bubble-strategy-case-study-dynamic-defensible-processes-change-salford", "date": "2007-04-01", "notes": "SCiO record for Peter Kawalek's action-research case on protected, defensible pockets of change.", "creators": [ "Peter Kawalek" ], "doi": "", "isbn": "", "publisher": "International Journal of Public Sector Management", "licence": "publisher_terms", "archived_url": "", "content_hash": "", "review_status": "checked", "last_checked": "2026-08-09", "public_link_status": "public_link" }, { "id": "src_principia_global_brain", "title": "The Global Brain Group", "source_type": "primary_project_page", "quality_tier": "A", "access": "public", "url": "https://pespmc1.vub.ac.be/GBRAIN-L.html", "date": "", "notes": "Primary Principia Cybernetica page on the Global Brain Group and programme.", "creators": [], "doi": "", "isbn": "", "publisher": "Principia Cybernetica Project", "licence": "source_terms", "archived_url": "", "content_hash": "", "review_status": "checked", "last_checked": "2026-08-10", "public_link_status": "public_link" }, { "id": "src_principia_intro", "title": "Introduction to Principia Cybernetica", "source_type": "primary_project_page", "quality_tier": "A", "access": "public", "url": "https://pespmc1.vub.ac.be/INTRO.html", "date": "", "notes": "Primary project-authored orientation page.", "creators": [], "doi": "", "isbn": "", "publisher": "Principia Cybernetica Project", "licence": "source_terms", "archived_url": "", "content_hash": "", "review_status": "checked", "last_checked": "2026-08-10", "public_link_status": "public_link" }, { "id": "src_sp26_f455a61e7d99311f", "title": "Designing Social Systems in a Changing World", "source_type": "public_catalogue_record", "quality_tier": "C", "access": "public", "url": "https://doi.org/10.1007/978-1-4757-9981-1", "date": "2026-09-19", "notes": "Opening title and DOI; Crossref publisher metadata. Bibliographic identity matched; source text indexed. Identity and located teaching relationships are separated from automatic title matches and exact text mentions. A term appearing in a source is not proof of its definition, endorsement, influence, or logical dependence.", "creators": [ "Bela H. Banathy" ], "doi": "", "isbn": "", "publisher": "Springer US", "licence": "source terms unless otherwise stated", "archived_url": "", "content_hash": "", "review_status": "located_public_record", "last_checked": "2026-09-19", "public_link_status": "public_link", "connection_pass": "library_20260919", "year": "1996" }, { "id": "src_sp26_a7bf870141f1233d", "title": "Learning as an activity of interdependent people", "source_type": "public_catalogue_record", "quality_tier": "C", "access": "public", "url": "https://doi.org/10.1108/09696470310497159", "date": "2026-09-19", "notes": "Opening title and DOI; Crossref publisher metadata. Bibliographic identity matched; source text indexed. Identity and located teaching relationships are separated from automatic title matches and exact text mentions. A term appearing in a source is not proof of its definition, endorsement, influence, or logical dependence.", "creators": [ "Ralph Stacey" ], "doi": "", "isbn": "", "publisher": "Emerald", "licence": "source terms unless otherwise stated", "archived_url": "", "content_hash": "", "review_status": "located_public_record", "last_checked": "2026-09-19", "public_link_status": "public_link", "connection_pass": "library_20260919", "year": "2003" }, { "id": "src_sp26_a63f52d3fe0bc7c0", "title": "Systems Approaches to Managing Change: A Practical Guide", "source_type": "public_catalogue_record", "quality_tier": "C", "access": "public", "url": "https://doi.org/10.1007/978-1-84882-809-4", "date": "2026-09-19", "notes": "Opening title and DOI; Crossref publisher metadata. Bibliographic identity matched; source text indexed. Identity and located teaching relationships are separated from automatic title matches and exact text mentions. A term appearing in a source is not proof of its definition, endorsement, influence, or logical dependence.", "creators": [], "doi": "", "isbn": "", "publisher": "Springer London", "licence": "source terms unless otherwise stated", "archived_url": "", "content_hash": "", "review_status": "located_public_record", "last_checked": "2026-09-19", "public_link_status": "public_link", "connection_pass": "library_20260919", "year": "2010" }, { "id": "src_sp26_70ea58555bf5f8be", "title": "Gaia Theory: Between Autopoiesis and Sympoiesis", "source_type": "public_catalogue_record", "quality_tier": "C", "access": "public", "url": "https://doi.org/10.15388/Problemos.98.13", "date": "2026-09-19", "notes": "Opening title and DOI; Crossref publisher metadata. Bibliographic identity matched; source text indexed. Identity and located teaching relationships are separated from automatic title matches and exact text mentions. A term appearing in a source is not proof of its definition, endorsement, influence, or logical dependence.", "creators": [ "Audronė Žukauskaitė" ], "doi": "", "isbn": "", "publisher": "Vilnius University Press", "licence": "source terms unless otherwise stated", "archived_url": "", "content_hash": "", "review_status": "located_public_record", "last_checked": "2026-09-19", "public_link_status": "public_link", "connection_pass": "library_20260919", "year": "2020" }, { "id": "src_sp26_2b9130787f8b4a27", "title": "Quantifying the Complexity of Socio-technical Systems – A Generic, Interdisciplinary Approach", "source_type": "public_catalogue_record", "quality_tier": "C", "access": "public", "url": "https://doi.org/10.1016/j.procs.2015.03.019", "date": "2026-09-19", "notes": "Opening title and DOI; Crossref publisher metadata. Bibliographic identity matched; source text indexed. Identity and located teaching relationships are separated from automatic title matches and exact text mentions. A term appearing in a source is not proof of its definition, endorsement, influence, or logical dependence.", "creators": [ "Florian Schöttl", "Udo Lindemann" ], "doi": "", "isbn": "", "publisher": "Elsevier BV", "licence": "source terms unless otherwise stated", "archived_url": "", "content_hash": "", "review_status": "located_public_record", "last_checked": "2026-09-19", "public_link_status": "public_link", "connection_pass": "library_20260919", "year": "2015" }, { "id": "src_u31_bhaskar", "title": "Bhaskar: mechanisms in open systems: researcher module", "source_type": "public_source", "quality_tier": "B", "access": "public", "url": "https://rational-understanding.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/bhaskar-researcher-module.pdf", "date": "2026", "notes": "John A Challoner’s version 1 reconstruction, 30 September 2026. General and specialised definitions/propositions are labelled separately; original-author wording is not implied.", "creators": [ "John A Challoner" ], "doi": "", "isbn": "", "publisher": "Rational Understanding", "licence": "source terms unless otherwise stated", "archived_url": "", "content_hash": "06ee89f8fbe01db4d9803b3579cc86359b3ccb34da86e0c7ab77e868900f0155", "review_status": "source_scoped_research_pass", "last_checked": "2026-10-08", "public_link_status": "public_link", "connection_pass": "update_20261008", "source_locator": "Complete PDF, 7 pages; specific claims carry page and proposition references", "source_role": "secondary reconstruction", "pages_read": 7 }, { "id": "src_taylor_outcomes_complexity_2025", "title": "Outcomes are the results of complex adaptive systems", "source_type": "public_teaching_material", "quality_tier": "C", "access": "public", "url": "https://antlerboy.com/library/files/talks/outcomes-and-complex-adaptive-systems.pdf", "date": "2025-06-06", "notes": "Public teaching presentation. Public PDF linked on 2026-09-19; the earlier unpublished access description is superseded.", "creators": [ "Benjamin P Taylor" ], "doi": "", "isbn": "", "publisher": "Benjamin P Taylor public work library", "licence": "not_publicly_licensed", "archived_url": "", "content_hash": "", "review_status": "public_file_identity_checked", "last_checked": "2026-09-19", "public_link_status": "public_link" } ], "evidence_locators": [ { "id": "ev_sfi_emergence_self_organisation", "source_id": "src_sfi_emergence_self_organisation_2022", "locator": "Seminar abstract, paragraphs 2-3", "review_status": "research_pass_needs_editor" }, { "id": "ev_sep_emergence_dependence_autonomy", "source_id": "src_sep_emergent_properties_2022", "locator": "overview of emergence and weak/strong varieties", "review_status": "research_pass_needs_editor" }, { "id": "ev_taylor_core_distinctions_boundaries", "source_id": "src_taylor_core_thinking_2026", "locator": "sections beginning 'systems work is not mapping the system' and 'a system boundary is not innocent'", "review_status": "research_pass_needs_editor" }, { "id": "ev_e31_module_bhaskar_3", "source_id": "src_u31_bhaskar", "locator": "p. 4, PG4", "review_status": "research_pass_needs_editor" }, { "id": "ev_taylor_outcomes_conditions", "source_id": "src_taylor_outcomes_complexity_2025", "locator": "slides 1-2 and 10-14", "review_status": "research_pass_needs_editor" } ], "reuse_note": "Preserve source attribution, scope, and review status. Source documents and evidence excerpts are excluded." }